Finding magic mushrooms online can be a difficult and daunting task. The active compounds in psychedelic shrooms are illegal. Even though you can still find them in some places, the broader market is sketchy — to say the least.

Navigating unregulated markets is a challenge at the best of times. It’s difficult to find reputable shroom vendors that are legal, legitimate, and have products that are safe to consume.

Although psilocybin-containing magic mushrooms are illegal in most countries, there’s another species of psychoactive mushroom that’s completely legal in the United States. This mushroom, called Amanita muscaria, doesn’t contain any psilocybin — but they do contain another psychoactive compound called muscimol.

Amanita is available to buy online, but it can be hard to find a legitimate, quality source. Here, we’ll explore the challenges of buying magic shrooms online and examine one of the best alternatives currently available — the Magic Pluto Mushroom Gummies from the folks at Area 52.

Quick Roundup: Top 7 Best Shroom Products Online

  1. Area 52: Magic Pluto Mushroom Gummies (Best Legal Option)

  2. Amanita Mushroom Gummies by Royal (Runner-Up)

  3. TRE House: Magic Mushroom Chocolates

  4. Koi: MusciMind Gummies

  5. Mycrocybin: Genesis Capsules

  6. Mushroom Lyfe: Euphoric Mushroom Gummies

  7. Exhale Amanita Mushroom Gummies

  8. BudPop: Amanita Muscaria Mushroom Gummies

#1: The Best Legal Mushroom Gummies: Area 52 Magic Pluto Mushroom Gummies

The Area 52 Magic Pluto Mushroom gummies have been formulated by a group of master herbalists and psychedelics experts. After years of testing through trial and error, Area 52 has finally developed a formula that’s potent, consistent, and worlds apart from other Amanita gummies on the market.

The Magic Pluto gummies are made using a full spectrum Amanita muscaria extract. They don’t just contain muscimol but also a host of other active compounds present in the mushrooms.

Retaining as much of the mushroom’s chemical profile as possible ensures that users experience the true effects of Amanita rather than a dulled-down experience from muscimol alone. These gummies are also combined with a carefully formulated combination of natural ingredients that work synergistically to enhance the effects of the mushroom extract…

What’s Inside the Area 52 Pluto Gummies?

The Area 52 Pluto gummies combine eight essential ingredients that work symbiotically to induce a dream-like sense of reality.

A range of psychoactive plant extracts and natural adaptogens have been combined to enhance the effects of the Amanita muscaria extract. This makes for a more potent product with a wider range of effects.

Here’s what’s inside the Magic Pluto gummies:

1. Muscimol

Muscimol is the active ingredient in Amanita muscaria mushroom gummies. It produces feelings of lucidity that can be described as bizarre, surreal, and dreamlike in conscious individuals. The fun doesn’t end when you fall asleep. Functioning as a potent dream catalyst, muscimol acts as a bridge between the realms of waking reality and surreal dreamscapes.

2. Blue Lotus Flower

Utilized by the ancient Egyptians and Syrians, the blue lotus flower (Nymphaea caerulea) was employed to induce trance-like states. Today, it’s consumed for the enhancement of lucid dreaming — characterized by full awareness and control of a person’s subconscious self in the dream realm.

Its psychoactive effects and ability to influence dreams complement the impacts of muscimol, making for a more lucid experience during sleep.

3. Dream Herb

The dream herb — known scientifically as Calea zacatechichi — originates as a shamanic herb from Central and South America. Similar to the blue lotus flower, this herb has played a role in rituals for millennia, facilitating shamanic communication with “alternate realms.”

The dream herb complements the effects of Amanita muscaria beautifully by improving vividness and activity in both conscious and unconscious dreamlike states.

4. Ashwagandha

Ashwagandha — also known as Withania somnifera or “Indian ginseng” — is an ancient medicinal herb that originates from India. It’s commonly used to reduce stress and anxiety, increase energy and stamina, improve cognitive function, and improve sleep.

This adaptogen has been added for its balancing properties. It helps moderate the impact of the other, more psychoactive herbs in the Magic Pluto gummies.

5. L-Theanine

L-theanine is an amino-acid isomer that’s extracted from Camellia sinensis (green tea) leaves. It’s believed to support cognitive function, sleep, and relaxation. It has been included in the Magic Pluto gummies because it helps shift brain activity toward the alpha frequency (8–12 Hz).

Alpha brain waves promote relaxation and calm focus, making L-theanine the perfect synergistic ingredient for controlling the effects of the more potent mind-bending ingredients in the gummies.

6. Full-Spectrum Hemp Extract

The Magic Pluto gummies contain the same full-spectrum hemp extract used in the Area 52 UFO gummies; you get CBD, CBG, CBN, CBC, and 10 mg of THC (under the legal threshold of 0.3%).

The addition of this full-spectrum extract helps reduce anxiety and stress while adding a sense of calm to the experience.

7. 5-HTP

5-HTP is an amino acid that serves as the precursor for serotonin and melatonin. These two important neurotransmitters are vital in mood and sleep regulation. This ingredient has been added to the Magic Pluto gummies to stabilize fluctuations in these two neurotransmitters that may be caused by the visionary plants and fungi in the edibles.

This component may assist in alleviating any drowsiness or grogginess that might occur as the effects of the gummies diminish.

8. Vitamin B6

Vitamin B6 is an essential component involved in more than 100 enzyme reactions in the body, with a key role in supporting the synthesis of neurotransmitters. By combining B6 with 5-HTP (mentioned above), the two work synergistically to enhance and maintain optimal neurotransmitter levels throughout and after the experience.

Runner Up: Royal Amanita Mushroom Gummies


Royal has been manufacturing top-tier CBD and THC gummies for years now. Many people have been anticipating the release of their new legal magic mushroom gummies since they were first announced last november.

These gummies blend a high-potency, muscimol extract derived from the Amanita muscaria mushroom, with their best-selling full-spectrum hemp extract (10 mg THC + 25 mg CBD).

Years of meticulous research and development have led to this moment, underscoring Royal’s principle of not rushing perfection. Unlike many competitors, Royal waited until they could guarantee the unparalleled quality of these gummies — steering clear of the low-grade ingredients saturating the market right now.

While not as strong as the Area 52 gummies, the Royal Amanita Mushroom Gummies represent some of the best value for consumers seeking legal mind-expansion without the steep pricetag. They boast the same high 10 mg dose of muscimol found in other premium offerings but come at a more accessible cost.

Inside the Royal Amanita Mushroom Gummies: Focus Formula, you’ll find:

  • 10 mg muscimol for powerful cognitive effects

  • Full-spectrum hemp extract standardized to contain 10 mg delta-9 THC

  • Ashwagandha extract for calmness & tranquility

  • Blue lotus flower for enhanced dream-incuding effects

  • Mexican dream herb for added lucidity

  • 5HTP to support melatonin and serotonin production

  • B vitamins for sustained energy

The Problem With “Legal Shroom” Products

New magic mushroom products are popping up around headshops and online marketplaces all the time. Unfortunately, many of the gummies available are sub-par and don’t work as intended. None of the legal options contain psilocybin (a Schedule I drug) and most of the legal versions use synthetic muscimol rather than a true Amanita extract, which doesn’t induce the same level of effects.

The truth is Amanita muscaria is a difficult mushroom to work with, and creating reliable and consistent extracts from raw mushrooms is difficult. Most companies don’t have the time or resources to perfect an extraction technique, so many opt to sell low-quality Amanita gummies, mushroom chocolate bars, or other edibles. These edibles often contain synthetic muscimol or other lab-made psychedelic compounds.

The major risks come when companies manufacture gummies that contain potentially harmful research chemicals such as 4-AcO-DMT. Sometimes, these chemicals are mixed in ratios that can cause serious psychological distress or are combined with other compounds that increase their toxicity.

Are Magic Mushrooms Legal?

No. Magic mushrooms — fungi that produce the psychedelic tryptamine psilocybin — are illegal in most countries. Apart from a few countries that have relaxed their laws, such as Jamaica, the Netherlands, and Austria, the production, possession, and consumption of magic mushrooms remains illegal.

Even though certain states in the United States have begun relaxing their psilocybin laws, obtaining magic mushrooms locally is heavily controlled and almost impossible for the average person.

Most states with “relaxed psilocybin laws” have only legalized mushrooms for medical use. Individuals must go through state-approved psychedelic centers to gain access to the psychedelic mushrooms.

In Canada, law enforcement is far more lenient in terms of magic mushroom consumption and possession. However, psilocybin remains illegal. Although it’s uncommon to receive a harsh penalty for the possession of shrooms, it’s still possible to face prosecution in the country.

Unless you want to commit an offense, buying magic mushrooms online in the United States, Canada, or Europe is a risky move.

Luckily, there are a few legal alternatives for those who wish to experiment with natural psychoactive mushrooms. Although psilocybin-producing mushrooms are illegal in most countries, fungi that produce the psychoactive compound muscimol are generally unrestricted.

Amanita muscaria: The Best Legal Alternative

Amanita muscaria — also known as the fly agaric mushroom — is a good legal alternative to psilocybin mushrooms. This species is the most recognizable mushroom on the planet. With a red cap and white spots, it’s associated with fairytales and fantasy. Its image has been featured in numerous artworks, films, and games — Alice in Wonderland, Fantasia, and Super Mario, to name a few.

This species grows across the globe, nestled in coniferous, deciduous, and mixed forests — adding vibrant colors of red and white to the forest floor. They spring up in the fall months in staggering numbers before disappearing as fast as they sprouted as the weather cools and autumn turns to winter.

Many people believe that Amanita muscaria is poisonous, which is correct to some degree. However, it’s nowhere near as deadly as many believe. Eating a fresh cap is likely to cause stomach upset, but when prepared correctly, gastric symptoms dissipate, and its psychoactive properties become more apparent.

There are two main active compounds in Amanita muscaria mushrooms. The first is ibotenic acid — the compound responsible for the negative effects associated with the shroom. The second is muscimol — a psychoactive compound that can induce dream-like states of consciousness.

When prepared correctly, the ibotenic acid present in Amanita mushrooms can be converted into the far more palatable and enjoyable compound muscimol.

Muscimol is different from psilocybin. Amanita is far less trippy and doesn’t induce vivid hallucinations like psilocybin mushroom species such as Psilocybe cubensis. Instead, muscimol induces a dreamlike sense of reality where “things aren’t quite as they seem.”

The effects of muscimolinclude:

  • Uplifted sensation

  • Lucidity

  • Dreamlike states

  • Altered time perception

  • Altered size & weight perception

  • The feeling of floating or flying

  • Heightened sensory awareness

  • Increased dream activity

  • Confusion

  • Sleepiness

Combining properly prepared Amanita muscaria mushrooms with a carefully formulated combination of adaptogens can further enhance the effects of muscimol. A good Amanita extract utilizes several different naturally occurring compounds that improve the psychoactive effects of the mushrooms. This is where many manufacturers fail.

What Are the Risks of Buying Shrooms Online

It’s entirely possible to buy psychedelic mushrooms online in Canada and the United States. Even though psilocybin is illegal in both countries, several online magic mushroom vendors operate efficiently across North America. However, there are several concerns that should be assessed before placing an order from one of these vendors.

There are two main issues when it comes to magic mushrooms and psilocybin edibles that are sold online:

1. Legal Repercussions

Psilocybin is an illegal substance in the United States. The government isn’t as lenient on psychedelics as it is in Canada. When ordering psilocybin-containing mushrooms online in the US, you’re committing a criminal offense and run the risk of prosecution.

It’s not unlikely to get caught buying mushrooms over the internet, either. Sometimes, organizations selling magic mushrooms over the internet will be shut down by law enforcement, but the vendor’s website will remain open. Law enforcement then uses the website to obtain customer information.

If you’re unlucky enough to order shrooms from a seized website that’s a “police honeypot,” you could end up with an unexpected visit from the law…

Ordering shrooms online and getting caught in the act can have some harsh penalties. You could receive fines, a criminal record, and even imprisonment, depending on the state you live in.

2. Unethical Practices

Due to the laws surrounding psilocybin, there are a lot of unethical companies that are straight-up scams. Some “magic mushroom vendors” are set up to appear as though they’re selling psilocybin mushrooms and edibles but simply take the customer’s money and never send anything. These people know that customers aren’t going to pursue legal means to retrieve their stolen money because what they order is restricted by law.

Other companies simply send out inactive “mushroom” edibles that induce no psychedelic effects at all — no one is going to file a complaint to the FTC about a product that didn’t contain the illegal substance they ordered.

Some companies want their customers to return and buy their products, so they make sure they induce a psychedelic experience. However, psilocybin from natural sources may not be used. Several products are circulating the market that contain psychedelic research chemicals, such as 4-AcO-DMT.

These chemicals are often stronger and more dangerous than psilocybin from magic mushrooms and can be mixed in uneven concentrations. Users who expect to eat chocolate containing psilocybin could be in for a psychologically distressing experience if a stronger research chemical has been used.

Of course, some companies are ethical and utilize real magic mushrooms when making edibles, capsules, and tinctures. However, it’s impossible to know what’s inside a particular product sold in this black market trade.

Frequently Asked Questions

If you’re interested in magic mushrooms and want to learn more, have a read through the five FAQs below. You may get an answer to a question you’ve been pondering on…

1. Is It Safe to Forage Wild Mushrooms for Psychedelic Use?

Foraging for any mushrooms, regardless of whether they’re edible, medicinal, or psychedelic, is not without its dangers. There’s always a risk of mistakenly harvesting a species that’s toxic and potentially lethal. However, with the right knowledge and education, it’s possible to mitigate the risks and reap the rewards.

If you wish to search for psychedelic mushrooms in the wild, you must educate yourself on the determining features of the species in question. It’s important to discover what psychedelic mushroom species are apparent around you and the time of year they grow.

Once you’ve set your sights on the species you want to discover, you must learn how to identify it. A mushroom identification guide and a bit of online research will help with this. You must also familiarize yourself with any potential look-alike species that could be misidentified. A local field guide will teach you about any toxic species present in the region.

After educating yourself about the species and its lookalikes, you can get out in the field foraging. If you come across what you believe to be the species in question, ensure that you’re 100% certain of its identity. It’s wise to get a second, third, or even fourth opinion before consuming any mushroom you find in the wild for the first time.

2. Can I Grow My Own Psychedelic Mushrooms Legally?

It’s possible to grow psychedelic mushrooms at home. It’s surprisingly easy to produce large amounts of hallucinogenic fungi with little in the way of knowledge, space, or time. However, it may not be legal to do so.

Psilocybin — the active compound in “magic mushrooms” — is a controlled substance in most countries. Mushrooms such as Psilocybe cubensis, Psilocybe semilanceata (Liberty Caps), and Psilocybe azurescens are illegal to possess, cultivate, and distribute across the United States, Canada, and most of Europe.

Other psychoactive fungi species that don’t contain psilocybin, such as those in the Amanita genus, may be legal to cultivate, depending on where you live. However, species in this genus are much more difficult to cultivate in an artificial environment because they depend on certain tree species and microorganisms.

3. What Are the Differences Between Various Strains of Psychedelic Mushrooms?

There are over 180 different species of psychedelic mushrooms. Many of these species are made up of genetic variants that portray differences in chemical makeup, appearance, and growth traits. We call these genetic variants “strains.”

The most genetically diverse species of psilocybin mushroom is Psilocybe cubensis. This species comprises hundreds of strains, many of which look and feel vastly different from one another.

Although all P. cubensis strains belong to the same species, they can differ from one another quite considerably.

Some strains, such as Penis Envy, have a unique phallic appearance and are capable of producing extremely high levels of psilocybin and psilocin. Other species, such as Golden Teacher, look more “mushroom-like” but produce lower psychedelic tryptamine levels.

Albino strains and strains with substantial genetic mutations also exist. They may have alterations in tryptamine levels and vast differences in shape, size, and color.

4. Are There Legal Consequences for Buying Psilocybin Mushrooms Online?

Psilocybin remains an illegal substance in most of the Western world. It’s illegal in the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom, most of Europe, Australia, and New Zealand.

Buying magic mushrooms online comes with legal risks. Like any crime, if you don’t get caught, you won’t get punished. However, if a package containing illegal magic mushrooms is intercepted and law enforcement can prove you purchased them, you run the risk of being prosecuted.

If you get caught purchasing psilocybin-containing magic mushrooms online in the United States, the penalty could be a simple fine or much worse, depending on the state. Europe is much the same. The penalty for purchasing magic mushrooms can vary from a warning or fine to community service or jail sentence, depending on the country